News By Tag
News By Place
Sarah Cox Esq. publishes Second Issue of Law Instruction Series, Seminar Business & Real Estate Law
Attorney Sarah Ellen Cox is publishing series of instructional articles, all of which will be available on her Blog; part 2 now available.
Ms. Cox summarizes the case. In action to enforce arbitral award against Belize, District of Columbia Circuit rejects Belize's claims of immunity because transactions at issue were essentially the sale of real estate and thus commercial in nature; New York Convention's definition of "commercial"
To go into more detail, in 2005, Belize Telemedia Limited ("Telemedia")
In November 2009, pursuant to section 207 of the Federal Arbitration Act ("FAA"), BSDL brought suit in the District Court for the District of Columbia to confirm the arbitral award. Belize moved to stay confirmation of the award pending resolution of related litigation in Belize, which the district court granted. BSDL then appealed.
The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reversed, noting that under the FAA, the stay order was not in conformity with federal law and international commitments. The Court remanded and instructed the district court to review and grant BSDL's petition to confirm the Final Award absent a finding that an enumerated exception to enforcement applied. On remand, Belize argued that the Prime Minister at the time of the entry of the agreement lacked authority to enter either the contract or the arbitration agreement, and that the district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction over the dispute claiming its sovereign immunity under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act ("FSIA"). Because Belize had not provided support for its claim with respect to the arbitration agreement, the district court held that jurisdiction was proper under the arbitration exception to the FSIA, and granted BSDL's petition to confirm the award. Belize appealed.
Sarah Cox notes that the court comes to the conclusion that: "(1) the Convention's purpose was to 'encourage the recognition and enforcement of commercial arbitration agreements in international contracts,' TermoRio S.A. E.S.P. v. Electranta S.P., 487 F.3d 928, 933 (D.C. Cir. 2007); (2) the word 'commercial' is a 'term of art'; and (3) in implementing the Convention, Congress intended that word to have the meaning generally attached to that term in the international commercial arbitration context. As we discussed above, 'commercial' in the context of international arbitration refers to matters which have a connection to commerce. Belize's argument to the contrary will not sell." The Court thus affirms the District Court's decision.
Ms. Cox comments that the DC Circuit rejects Belize's claims of immunity because transactions at issue were about real estate. Note that the New York Convention's definition of "commercial"
The Case Citation is Belize Social Development Ltd. v. Government of Belize, No. 14-7002 (D.C. Cir.). The article will be published in full on the Blog of Sarah Cox at https://SarahECoxBlog.blogspot.com
About Sarah E. Cox
Sarah E. Cox is a Personal Injury & Real Estate Attorney in Fort Myers, Florida.
Attorney Profile at: https://solomonlawguild.com/
Blog at: https://SarahECoxBlog.blogspot.com
Law Office of Sarah Cox & Associates, LLC
Sarah E. Cox, Esq.