CSA 2010 Successfully Defeneded by FMCSA in Federal Court and Fights Off Attempt at Inunction

Dec. 19, 2010 - PRLog -- http://blog.freightaccess.com/2010/12/trucking-associations-unsuccessful-against-fmcsas-csa-2010-legislation/

By: Brad Hollister.

On November Twenty ninth, 2010, three Leading U . S . Trucking Associations, representing greater than 3,000 privately owned fleets, registered the motion at the United States Court of Appeals in order to review the execution of this FMCSA 's CSA  (CSA) 2010 legislation. The Carrier Lobbying Associations are seeking a permanent injunction from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's release of the contentious carrier safety scores as defined in the FMCSA's contentious safety regulation.

All of these Truck Carrier Associations have been previously denied a temporary termination order to stop implementation of CSA 2010 safety scores for the open public, when these three thousand in addition privately owned or operated fleets had submitted the main injunction on December 10, 2010. The Federal Court had agreed to issue an expedited deliberation to hear oral arguments by each party about the merit to issuing this stoppage order from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA ) with the release of this CSA  statistics under the CSA 2010 initiative.

The Three Freight Carrier Associations trying to find the injunction happen to be the Expedited Alliance of North America (TEANA), the Air & Expedited Motor Carrier Association (AEMCA), plus the National Association of Small Trucking Companies (NASTC). Together, these three Trucking Associations are generally opposing the implementation of CSA  (CSA) information arguing that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA ) does not fully understand the huge effect the release of this driver safety information will have on the small carriers.
Under the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA ) regulation, the CSA  2010 (CSA 2010) will make all of details offered to online visitors. This info does not only report every citation, warning, safety incident, accident, in addition to out of service orders to the public for every single Carrier, but also for each and every truck driver. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration will work having virtually all ruling agencies to provide a complete and comprehensive report surrounding the Behavioral Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (Referred to by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration as BASICs).

The BASICs categories are comprised of the following requirements for each freight carrier as well as truck driver: unsafe driving, driving when fatigued, drivers unfit to operate a commercial vehicle, operation of a vehicle while impaired due to alcohol or drugs, improper maintenance, and collision instances experience. These trucking organizations have provided arguments how the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA )'s release of this Comprehensive Safety Administration statistics.

The Truck Rental Industry continues to be debating the issue of vicarious liability for years. When a party is working on your account (known or unknown), vicarious liability is created by either an action or non-action. Even though the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration oversees carriers, freight brokers, logistics companies, and shippers as a client from the freight carrier (either directly or indirectly) can be found vicariously liability or negligence when finding a freight carrier or truck driver.

Numerous ground breaking cases have already been adequately introduced and damages or injuries awarded coming from companies which did not have direct affect in the evaluation of the service provider. The three trucking associations trying to get this injunction against the release of CSA  (CSA) data from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA ): Expedited Alliance of North America (TEANA), the Air & Expedited Motor Carrier Association (AEMCA), and the National Association of Small Trucking Companies (NASTC) and several others are worried that freight brokers, logistics companies freight forwarders, intermodal carriers, warehousing firms, and shippers could feel obligated to choose primarily freight carriers and truck drivers together with only the highest possible safety scores for fear of additional culpability by an improper freight carrier or owner operator decision.

In 2004, a Maryland court decision held a third party logistics corporation accountable for the negligent hiring of a carrier which induced a major accident because the firm didn't take the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) safety status of the freight carrier into consideration before employing the trucking company (Shramm vs. Foster).

This hot button issue of this new legislation will definitely continue into 2011. For now these trucking associations failed to prove damages brought on by the CSA 2010 initiative. The court has made the decision oral arguments presented on behalf of the 3,000 freight carriers thus far are actually ruled to be predicted or forecasted, damages, not actual damages. Thus the courts have consistent upheld the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's (FMCSA ) governance over the issue. Time will tell if the trucking industry will probably be successful in demonstrating damages as a direct result of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration?s (FMCSA ) latest CSA  regulation known as CSA 2010.

Brad Hollister. is an Experienced Transportation Executive with a passion for Business Development through innovation, process improvement, and technology. Feel free to contact me with any inquiries, opportunities, or suggestions or by visiting http://www.freightaccess.com .

http://blog.freightaccess.com/2010/12/trucking-associatio...

# # #

Welcome to Freight Access.com, the World's First Transportation Marketplace where Shippers, Brokers, Carriers, and Owner Operators can find loads, find freight and make calculated business decisions. Visit www.freightaccess.com to join for free.