The UK and the Budget: Shaw Capital Management Korea

Nov. 22, 2010 - PRLog -- In the UK it is obvious that there is no possibility of continuing with budget deficits of some 13% of GDP, the present prospect if no action is taken.

Unfortunately however the recent UK Budget produced no credible plan for dealing with this problem. It swept it into the lap of the new government after the May election, whatever that government is.

The UK and the Budget: Shaw Capital Management Korea. The UK cannot delude themselves that rapid resumed growth will lead to a rapid return of the previous revenue streams. UK growth in most forecasts, ours included, is projected as slow. In our view there is a good reason: the continuing shortage of oil and raw materials worldwide prevents rapid growth for the world
as a whole and since emerging market economies are continuing to grow rapidly that restricts the growth possibilities in countries like the UK and other developed countries.

We are already seeing inflation spread into China and other emerging countries, forcing a tightening of policy.

It seems likely that this tightening will be enough to restrain world growth to rates that will not push commodity prices much higher. So even the fast-growing world economies are being forced to limit their growth ambitions; as for the UK they are achieving ‘recovery’, but hardly enthusiastic growth.

All this will only change when innovation in raw material use has freed up net world supplies.

Fortunately the flexibility of the UK labour market has restricted the jobs fallout. Unemployment has peaked below 8% (just over 5% on the benefit-claimant measure) as people have opted for wage freezes or cuts and shorter hours … so there is underemployment
but not the disaster of double-digit unemployment rates. But this environment is one in which tax revenues will not recover much and in which the demands for public spending will continue.
Time will tell how big the ‘structural deficit’ … that will emerge once the recovery is complete … may be.

But policy decisions cannot wait until this is better known. So in this Budget the need was to produce a five-year public sector adjustment plan.

Two things should guide this plan: keeping the taxes down and competitive, so that growth and innovation resume, and restoring efficiency in public spending.

The UK and the Budget: Shaw Capital Management Korea. Spending cuts to begin with the last, the current government unleashed a massive surge in public spending from 2000, raising it by 8% of GDP before the crisis raised it by more again.

Everyone knew that without reform and gradual increases, such money would be wasted; there is no practical way to spend such vast sums without raising wages and wasting money on speculative projects.

Productivity in the public sector duly slumped and public sector remuneration including pensions has surged past the private sector where market forces suggest pay should be higher to reflect greater insecurity.

The UK and the Budget: Shaw Capital Management Korea. To reduce public spending back to where it started in 2000 as a share of GDP (at around 36%) would require it to grow in real terms by about 16% less than real GDP over the next five years. Since total GDP growth over that period is likely to be about 10%, which means that spending must be cut by about 1% a year in real terms.

This is a feasible target. The UK Treasury under Gordon Brown became a brute instrument of spending increase, oddly somewhat against the protests of some departments worrying about wasteful effects. The UK Treasury was never traditionally like this … very much the opposite, a place from which wringing money was like getting blood from stones.

It should be returned to its traditional function of restraint; Treasury control, old-style, is the best instrument for forcing departments to find the economies they privately know they can make.

# # #

Shaw Capital Management, Korea - Investment Innovation & Excellence. We provide the information, insight and expertise that you need to make the right investment choices. Shaw Capital Management Korea typically offers its clients such services as asset allocation and portfolio design; traditional and non-traditional manager review and selection; portfolio implementation; portfolio monitoring and consolidated performance reporting; and other wealth management services, including estate, tax, trust and insurance planning, asset custody, closely held business issues associated with the establishment or expansion of a family office, the formation of family investment partnerships or LLCs, philanthropy, family dynamics and inter-generation issues, etc.