News By Tag
News By Location
Why Muslims hate Zakir Naik so much
Summary of reasons why progressive Muslims hate Zakir Naik so much and believe that he is disgracing Islam. Must read for everyone concerned about humanity, peace, rise of terrorism, women rights and peaceful coexistence.
Dr Zakir Naik has been among the most hated public figures of today. He claims to represent and propagate Islam. Yet it is the Muslims and Islamic clerics who hate Zakir Naik the most. Many claim that he would be the first person to enter Hell.
Quran proclaims that one who submits to the word of final messenger of Allah shall achieve Heaven. But things are not so simple. Because there is a tremendous variety in the types of interpretations that Muslims make out of this book and this great social-reformer. The number of sects in Islam are more than 72 and they are as different from each other as dry is from wet and cold is from hot. All these sects have different customs, different levels of tolerances for non-Muslims, different food habits, different interpretations of Quran, different level of importance given to Muhammad and his associates and different descriptions of Heaven and Hell. The Shia-Sunni war is clearly known.
What makes the things even more confusing is the belief that of these 72+ sects only one is on path of truth. Each sect claims that they are the genuine sect. Some sects are liberal enough to allow even non-Muslims to Heaven. Some Muslims are promoters of vegetarianism. Some consider nation ahead of everything. But there are some like Wahabis who believe that only those who fully believe in their sect and its practices without questioning, alone will go to Heaven. Rest will be in Hell forever. They is supposed to be the producer of largest number of terrorists including Osama and Al Qaeda since its inception in 18th century and has been a cause of disgrace for rest of the peace-loving Muslims. Dr Zakir Naik belongs to this Wahabi cult, believes that only this Wahabi version of Islam can bring anyone close to Heaven, and rest of all will go to Hell. Further, he mixes Wahabism with his own concepts to create his own Zakirism, that in the process blatantly insults and disgraces the vision of Islam as per other sects, including the more tolerant ones. His Zakirism goes to such extent that he does not even spare Wahabis from humiliations. Let us see how:
a. Zakir Naik claims to be an expert of comparative religions and has lots of articles on comparative religions under his own name. But in reality, they are merely word to word copy of texts from Qadiyani/Ahmadiyya sources. Now:
- Qadiyanis/ Ahmadiyyas are considered Kafirs and are prosecuted by almost all Muslims .
- Wahabis have been greatest enemies of Qadiyanis
- The content of the Qadiyani writings that Zakir Bhai MBBS has swindled under his own name are blatantly against core beliefs of rest of the Muslims including Wahabis. For example, Zakir Bhai MBBS tries to prove that Vedas prophecize about Muhammad.
Now this belief gels with the Qadiyani belief that Vedas were also revelations. But Wahabis and other sects refuse to believe so. Hence even Zakir Bhai MBBS writes in another article that he is not sure if Vedas are revelations. He conveniently forgets that he himself has proved that Vedas reveal Muhammad in another article!
In summary, Zakir Bhai continues to use Qadiyani source to show his scholarly capabilities but refuses to accept Qadiyanis because he claims to be Wahabi and is funded by Wahabi militants.Or is he a Qadiyani spy in Wahabi disguise? Only Zakir Bhai knows the reality, but his acts suffice to invite hatred of Qadiyanis as well as other Muslim sects.
b. Zakir Bhai justifies non-vegetarianism as a scientific Islamic trait. While he does acknowledge that even a Muslim can be vegetarian, he attempts to justify meat-eating on crazy arguments including research by some farmers. This catches ire of several progressive Muslims who refuse to believe that meat-eating has any association with religion. Muslim Vegetarian Society is among the most powerful protagonists of Vegetarianism and opponents of Halal meat. They have severely condemned Zakir Naik and his spurious research for disgracing Islam to justify the lust of his own tongue. (You can visit their site at www.islamveg.com)
c. Being a Wahabi he has a soft corner for Osama Bin Laden. When someone questioned him on his views on Osama, he replied that he admires him because he has terrorized America! This created a lot of furore among Muslims and Deoband even issued a fatwa against Zakir Bhai for his tacit support for Osama Bin Laden. Many terrorists caught in past few years have admitted that they were inspired by rhetoric of Zakir Naik.
d. Wahabis have destroyed many Sufi shrines and even house of Prophet Muhammad. They killed many Muslim men, women and children in their campaigns to destroy tombs and holy places. In the same footsteps, Zakir justifies these attacks of Wahabis.
f. Shias obviously have a reason to hate Zakir Bhai MBBS because of his staunch anti-Shia stance, being a Wahabi. But his admiration of Yazeed, considered to be culprit for massacre of Karbala has been a strong point of contention for other Muslims.
g. Zakir justifies the ban on worship of other religions in Muslim countries. He however also justifies that Muslims should be allowed in other countries to promote their religion. The logic is curious – as per Zakir Bhai, in matters of religion, Muslims are the best. So they should be allowed everywhere – Muslim or non-Muslim countries. But non-Muslims should not be allowed to build places of worship in Muslim countries because their religions are inferior to Islam!
Such ultra-fanaticism irks the more progressive Muslims who want to integrate with rest of the world and rise above religious dogmas and hatred.
h. Being an ultra-conservative he propagates that despite a person being as much good or noble, unless he unconditionally accepts his version of Islam, he will go to Hell and Hell alone and forever.
i. Muslim women obviously have all the reasons to hate Zakir Bhai because in name of pseudo-science he is simply restricting their freedom that has been ordained by the Creator. For example, he states that Muslim women should always wear Hijab and Burqa and cover their entire body always. Medical researchers are worried that such unreasonable practices cause dreaded diseases due to lack of Vitamin D in Muslim countries which enforce such beliefs on women. More liberal Muslims see such insistence as dangerous dogma harming the cause of Muslims and Human Rights.
He further states that Muslim women should not work in offices because they may have chance to be alone with men even for a second. The only men that a woman is allowed to be alone with are her husband and those who have suckled her. Taking this crazy dogma of Zakir Bhai further, the Head of Hadith Department of the most reputed university of Islam in world recently issued a fatwa that Muslim women should allow their male colleagues to suckle them five times. This will allow them to work with these men, even when alone!
Zakir Bhai debars women from being any doctor except gynecologists because that is haram as per his version of Islam. Women should not take part in sports as well!
He further defends polygamy by furnishing false data on population but disallows polyandry.
He justifies the belief that women are less intelligent than men and hence evidence of two women equal that of one man! He thus also justifies that women cannot inherit equal to their male counterparts!
No wonder, he would agree to dogma that to prove a rape, a woman should bring ample number of witnesses who have witnessed actual penetration!
There is not even a scope for debate, and certain persons should be out-rightly banished to Hell or hell-like place for benefit of rest of the civilized peaceful society. The way noble-minded Muslims have shown courage and mettle to condemn the dangerous frauds of Zakir Bhai that are detrimental to entire humanity is warmly welcomed.
(To read the complete report and more such reports, visit http://agniveer.com)
# # #
Agniveer.com is dedicated to providing rational and logical analysis of life, living and purpose of it all. It aims to create awareness towards peaceful purposeful living with objectivity. Agniveer.com is solely dedicated to the religion of humanity.