Pushing the satire aside for a moment, this famous quote is a constant reminder to investors that although statistics are powerful tools to help us recognize relationships, it’s far more important to isolate and analyze the drivers of a relationship in order to profit in the future.
Investors often succumb to the dangers hidden within statistics simply because they carry very powerful psychological triggers. It’s human nature to want to believe statistics on face value, and often the work required to support or disprove a relationship is either daunting or deemed irrelevant given the observed strength in the relationship.
NOTE: Think about how many statistics are quoted during nightly news broadcasts on TV. Then think about how few of these figures are broken down to the point where they explain how the data was gathered and/or analyzed.
Furthermore, what may appear to be a relationship is often nothing more than coincidence. For example, visit the website, http://www.tylervigen.com/
Simply put, the danger for investors is that “spurious correlations”
Small Cap Stocks Are Correcting
There has been an extraordinary amount of chatter recently about the Russell 2000, which is an equity index that represents small-cap stocks totaling close to 10% of the total U.S. market capitalization.
Although this index may appear to be insignificant versus the larger S&P 500, investors use the Russell 2000 as a barometer for investors’ risk appetites because these investments typically offer shareholders a higher growth rate than larger companies. For example, a small tech startup can achieve annual growth rates well above 100%, whereas Apple would be difficult to see mid-teens growth rates given they already generate around $180 billion in revenue in a year.
When bulls are rampant in the market, the Russell 2000 seems to lead the charge. In fact, of the eight years since 2000 when equities ended positive, small-cap stocks averaged annual returns of around 23%. This figure is materially higher than the 16.4% return of the S&P 500 during the same time period.
The Russell 2000 had a fantastic 2013, delivering its best year since the tech boom in 2000 with returns of 36.8%. However, investors have been forced to endure a decline of almost 5% so far in 2014, and these stocks are down over 10% since their last peak, which had not happened since November 2012.
Wall Street tends to label a move greater than 10% down as a “correction”
What is most interesting here is that of the first 35 corrections, each one was accompanied by large-caps also falling around 13%, until now. Simply put, this seemingly obvious relationship predicated upon historical performance appears to have broken down (the S&P 500 is actually positive year-to-date)
The investors that merely observed this supposed relationship and then acted accordingly are currently scratching their heads. The Investment Committee, on the other hand, has done the work to deduct the real reason why small-cap stocks are correcting and large-caps are not.
Valuation Now Matters
We believe that small-cap stocks have corrected so sharply this year because the market has started to pay attention to valuation. Small-cap stocks flew too high too fast, and investors became nervous holding many stocks that trade at meteoric valuations with little to no earnings.
Large-cap stocks, on the other hand, are nowhere near as expensive. On a historic basis, the S&P 500 is trading in a range that the Investment Committee considers to be fairly valued. Simply put, large-caps are neither cheap nor expensive, and we therefore continue to be opportunistic and wait for cheap stocks to emerge that can offer attractive returns for our investors.
The bottom line is that the Investment Committee keeps a very close eye on valuation because we invest for the long term. Stocks that carry high valuations must prove that their future expected growth is real or else they will fiercely correct. Hence, we manage our downside by looking for quality/misunderstood stocks with valuations that are so low that it creates an implicit floor in the stock price.
Lastly, although statistics are certainly worth observing, investors should never take them on face value. Large-cap stocks don’t simply follow small-cap stocks blindly, and the year-to-date performance of the Russell 2000 and S&P 500 support this conclusion. Large-cap stocks continue to show strength because their valuations are lower and the economic data continue to point to a slowly growing economy.
Article Credit: Global Financial Private Capital, Comprehensive Wealth Management, LLC
Matt Golab was recruited to write a chapter in Tom Hopkins recent book, Victory which became a National Best Seller. Matt also received the Editors Choice Award for his contribution to Victory, not every contributor is selected for this high honor.
Matt is an authority on creating innovative tax and investment solutions to help his clients succeed in their retirement years. The strategies Matt Golab has established and passed on through successful financial planning with hundreds of clients over the years has launched him into the national spotlight.
Golab is often asked by national websites that focus on the education of consumers to present his knowledge on the areas of retirement and retirement income plans. Matt is frequently featured in The Wall Street Journal, CNBC, MSN Money, The San Francisco Chronicle, Newsweek, TheSmartRetiree, Burlington County Times and appeared nationwide on ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC as well as USA Today.
Matt has a weekly radio show where he discusses all aspects of retirement planning, total wealth management, and estate strategies. Through his relationship with Retirement Radio Network experts such as David Walker former Comptroller General of the United States, Harry Dent of the H.S. Dent Foundation, John Bogle of the Vanguard Funds and many more have been heard on his show Income Forever.
Matt emphatically states his mission, “I want to change the way Americans view their retirement. They can succeed (stay retired) regardless of what happens in the market". Contact information for Matt is available at his website,
Investment Advisory Services offered through Global Financial Private Capital, LLC, an SEC Registered Investment Advisor.