Speaking at a press conference held at the Russell Bedford International Tax & European Conference, Copenhagen on 14 May 2012, Brown was clear that market forces alone are unlikely to effect any greater degree of genuine market access for the mid-tier audit firms. Big Four market dominance will increase exponentially over the next decade, he claims, and only regulatory intervention is likely to deliver any greater access for the mid-tier at the top end of the listed markets. Would this situation, he asked, be tolerated in any other sector? ‘If we make no changes now, where will we be in 10 or 20 years? The gap will get wider and wider.’ This is a view echoed by Goodyear, who expressed some frustration at shareholders’
Brown anticipates no major developments before next year, however. While he suggests the European Parliament is keen to publish its conclusions after the UK’s Competition Commission, this is unlikely to happen before October next year.
Joint audit: EGIAN hopeful of a return to the agenda?
Responding to a question on potential revisions to the Barnier proposals, Brown gave a strong indication that, as far as EGIAN is concerned, joint audits could well return to the agenda. Many MEPs, he argued, are increasingly conscious that ‘something has to be done’; and many are looking to joint audits as part of a package of achieving greater market access. ‘There is a growing realisation that there are issues to be addressed in the audit market. And that’s a big change from two years ago.’
EGIAN, as is well known, sees joint audits as a possible mechanism for achieving better market access; Goodyear, however sees rotation and compulsory tendering as more immediate solutions, pointing to the Big Four’s far lesser dominance in the public sector – the direct result, he believes, of strict tendering requirements.
Shareholder (and client) views should enter the debate
Returning to a point he had raised repeatedly on the publication of the Barnier proposals, Geoff Goodyear again expressed frustration that debate on audit reform remains confined mainly to the profession, with shareholders apparently unaware of the real implications of current limitations on choice. This position Brown suggests is now changing: ‘What the Barnier proposals have done is to create a ferocious debate on the current position of the audit market. Views have changed; people previously not involved in the debate now realise there are issues to be tackled.’
Why don't the mid-tier firms invest and expand?
Responding to a question on the likelihood of further market concentration, Brown was quick to point out that such risks are further exacerbated at the bottom of the market. Experience in Scotland, he claimed, suggests there is a greater risk that the smallest firms will simply withdraw from the audit market altogether. According to Brown, for some at least, ‘it’s simply too expensive to stay in. Scotland now has some cities with no audit capacity at all.’ Big Four market dominance, moreover, has a further impact in discouraging investment by the mid-tier. ‘Why invest in a market where there is no market? No one is going to invest in a market where you have to wait 50 years for a chance to bid … if you don’t have a vibrant market, you don’t have innovation.’
A recording of the online broadcast of the press conference can be viewed at https://vimeo.com/
Notes for Editors
About Russell Bedford International
Established in 1983, Russell Bedford International is a global network of independent firms of accountants, auditors, tax advisers and business consultants.
Ranked amongst the world’s leading accounting and audit networks, Russell Bedford is represented by some 460 partners, 5000 staff and 200 offices in more than 80 countries in Europe, the Americas, the Middle East, Africa and Asia-Pacific.
Russell Bedford International is a member of EGIAN, the European Group of International Accounting Networks and Associations.
The European Group of International Accounting Networks and Associations is an association whose membership is made up of 22 truly global organisations which offer audit, accounting and business advisory services. The combined turnover of the members is US$ 32 billion.
EGIAN provides a forum for the members to develop common positions on specific technical and legislative issues and to debate these issues with key professional stakeholders and regulators such as the European Commission, the Committee of European Securities Regulators (CESR), the Federation of European Accountants (FEE) and the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC).
Russell Bedford International
Tel.: +44 20 7410 0339 /
+44 20 7410 0339 / 7490 7766 (UK)
+33 1 58 36 50 00 (France)
Mobile: +44 7905 870768 (UK) /
+33 6 32 29 94 41 (France)
European Group of International Accounting Networks and Associations
Tel.: +32 2 763 28 73